Kalamazoo, MI
one-hundred-forty-one Years of Service to the Student

Pizza's Kitchen

Why I Don’t Feel Comfortable in Gendered Spaces

Ever since I began to identify as someone who fits outside the gender binary, that is, not male or female, I’ve run into countless issues. From having my preferred name and pronouns disregarded, to not having a place to pee in the library, things people typically take for granted are an everyday hassle for me.

However, not everyone understands why that is. Last week, when I was talking to a friend about the new gender-neutral bathrooms in Hicks, she asked why I didn’t just use the gendered bathroom I felt most comfortable in. Since our campus is pretty liberal, she didn’t think others would mind.

While I have had countless “Oh’s” in surprise and people turning around to check the sign after they see me washing my hands to prove that people don’t think I belong there, that is not the only problem with that statement. I want to point out a common misconception about non-binary people: that we “feel more comfortable” with one binary gender over another.

This is completely false.

While I do tend to use the women’s bathroom and play on a women’s ultimate team, that doesn’t mean I’m content with my choices. Every time I am forced to “pick” a binary gender, I feel anything but comfortable.

Whether it’s hanging with a bunch of male-identified people who know I’m not a boy, or talking with female-identified people who assume I’m still a girl, I feel trapped remembering everything I’m not, and everything people expect me to be.

While gendering groups can be empowering and successful, especially for women’s groups, it is not inclusive to people who identify outside the binary. Some of these spaces are so strictly gendered that even binary transgender people feel uncomfortable.

To begin to remedy this injustice, I think all Student Organizations, and administration members who strongly believe that gendered-spaces can accommodate gender non-conforming individuals rethink their logic, because I am living proof that they do not.

So the next time you see a gendered space, think about why it’s gendered within the binary. Then, ask if the exclusion of trans-identified people validates the importance of those spaces being gendered.

Hopefully, this will make campus a more inclusive, and less uncomfortable, place for non-binary students like me.

1 Comment on Why I Don’t Feel Comfortable in Gendered Spaces

  1. If you get to interpret your gender fluidly then you must allow others the same option as some exclusively men’s/women’s groups may be comfortable with you being in their group. However, a doctor or surgeon cannot afford to interpret your gender – they must pay attention to your sex or it could cost you your life. Maybe it’s insulting to them that they have to remember to see past your gender and focus on your sex, on top of many other things in their day. How much does your gender crisis need to be about us? If I were a teacher, I wouldn’t have the mental capacity to remember a thousand different “preferred pronouns” so I’d either say “you,” your formal name or just avoid interacting with you. Most of us really aren’t trying to be rude you so please don’t make it seem like we are or that what you’re doing is some trivial thing. It’s no minor thing to say “Oh, by the way, I ID as _____ but anyway, how ’bout those Lions?”

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


Why I Don’t Feel Comfortable in Gendered Spaces